I am not the best person to ask to
comment on computer games. I appreciate what others find in them. But
for me...
My generation had the first Atari
consoles in elementary school. Pong! We grew up with the Video Arcade
at the mall. Asteroids! PacMan! We watched games on computers take
off...
Now I know that “video” games and
games on the computer are not one and the same. But there is some
overlap. I wonder how the two have informed each other over the
years...
I remember playing video games at my
friends' houses. As the kid with poor hand-eye coordination, I did
not enjoy it much. Here's how it always went down: it would happen at
a friend's house (never at mine, I never had any consoles or game
systems. Never asked for one, I think). My turn to play: I would die.
My friend's turn to play (It was their game; they played all the
time): “here I am doing this; watch me do this; this spot is
tricky; O, that was a close one.” I got to watch. I had not much
incentive to watch and learn what happens on level X because I would
never get beyond level 1)...
For this reason
and a few others, I have never cared much for electronic games. I see
people tuned out to other (real, non-virtual people) engrossed in
their computers, tables, phones, and devices doing social media, this
or that 'game” (and saying they're “working” usually!) I see my
kids not playing outside or reading, I see my wife doing FB on her
phone all evening... what does this have to do with educational
games? Enough for me; I don't draw a very fine line. It's all staring
at a screen...
Yes, I'm woefully
backwards, uncool, a Luddite, a square (and whatever my teen-aged
daughter can think up to call me). I don't get it. But I did try some
games. The one I liked is called Topropa. It's a geography game. I
kill at geography, so there is most of the attraction. And there's
not much to learn (good for someone with an abysmally low frustration
threshold when it comes to technology). Just match the river, or the
city, or the battle, or whatever on the map and find out immediately
if you're right. It is very probable that the reason I like it would
also be the same reason most people would not...
So what about
people who like computer games? (That's everybody but me, right?) I'm
glad for them. This is the golden age of computer games, by all
appearances. I'm glad there are some good games, some educational
games. I'm glad to talk to people about games and why they think they
are good. Tell me stories about a game! I will listen. Tell me if you
think there is a place for your game in my classroom. Just don't ask
me to play. Or to watch you play it for too long.
Hello John,
ReplyDeleteThank you for your post. I appreciate the transparency with which you discussed your relationship with video games throughout your life. Although we are not of the same generation, I feel we have similar experiences. I resonated with your comment, "My turn to play: I would die." That was two years of college "playing" Halo with my housemates. Lets just say video games are not really a strong suit of mine.
I am curious, though, what your thoughts are about modeling for your students. So far in this MAC program, modeling has come up several times and always follow by, "This is a good strategy for teachers!" Although you stated you would never play a game in class, what circumstances would cause you to model a game for them in the classroom?
Did I say I would not play in class? I was imagining talking to my fellow MACers about stuff and not about working with students in the classroom.
ReplyDeleteI may not understand your question, though. Do you mean my persona? (It would be different from how I am with my fellow MACers, of course!) As in modelling enthusiasm for a game? I'm not sure I'd need to do that. The students already have that!
A move I've used with success many times already is the Tell-me-about-this-I-don't-know-about-it act. Generally, I do know something about whatever it is, of course. But it makes the students feel good to be teaching me.
I'd use this with games in the classroom. I'd pick the game, vet it, make sure it's installed and all that. But I don't think i need to have played it all the way through myself. I'll let them do then. Then they can tell me about it. Or write about it.